Shop smarter with this beef cut that tastes like a premium roast. However, prime rib tends to be a little more flavorful than rib eye because it contains the bone and additional fat. The only pitfall that absolutely must be avoided with prime rib is over cooking that mortgage payment. I've bought quite a few of the ribeye variety over the years and except for one time when Ratz and I ruined one on the Big Easy, they have all turned out great. It is harvested from the rib primal portion of the rib section, in the upper rib cage of the cow, usually spanning ribs 6 through 12. Now you have the best of both worlds: the tenderest beef on the inside, with the most flavorful, seasoned outside. REST: Lay out two pieces of aluminum foil and carefully transfer the prime rib from the roasting tray. In terms of tenderness, the filet will often beat out just about any other steak cut you pit it against. Top loin roast, which comes from the short loin in the middle of the cow’s back, is the roast that generates strip steaks (it’s also called “strip roast”). ROAST: Place the prime rib in the oven or pellet grill and cook until the internal temperature of the prime rib is 120 F for rare or up to 130 F for medium rare, about 3 1/4 – 3 1/2 hours for rare and a little longer for medium rare. Letting it hang out like that on its ownsome for about 30 – 45 minutes in between the cooking and browning phases lets all the meat juices do their magical thing – without over cooking or drying out. (On the Traeger, use the probes that come with the pellet grill; for the oven, an ideal model would be one that reads the temperature continuously and displays it outside the oven, so that you can avoid opening the oven repeatedly to check the temperature, like this one.). ★☆ As usual, much appreciate responses. Ribeye steak comes, as the name suggests, from the rib section of beef. This is a trick I actually borrowed from smoking and bbqing over the summer. Learn real cooking skills from your favorite food experts, The iconic magazine that investigates how and why recipes work, American classics, everyday favorites, and the stories behind them, Experts teach 200+ online courses for home cooks at every skill level, Kid tested, kid approved: Welcome to America’s Test Kitchen for the next generation, Fresh Flavors Sale: Exclusive Equipment Deals - Save Up to 50%. (Thank goodness, because it isn’t cheap.). Required fields are marked *, Rate this recipe ★☆. Leave the roast out at room temperature for two hours on a wire rack to cure and drain out some of the excess liquid. Thus, we can also say ribeye steak is a part of the prime rib. Strictly speaking, the term “prime rib” is a misnomer that has taken on its own meaning through commonly accepted misuse—many people think it’s synonymous with “rib roast.” However, the word prime is a quality-grade designation assigned by the USDA. Remove the prime rib from the oven or pellet grill and take out the probe. ★☆ Carefully unwrap the foil and pour off any juices, then transfer the prime rib back to a roasting tray or baking sheet. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Place a meat thermometer probe into the middle of the prime rib roast, pushing it mid way into the thickness of the meat & avoiding any bones. I’ve never made prime rib at home, but you’ve got me itching to try it out. This is, NEW RECIPE: Crispiest Roast Sheet Pan Chicken with, Mr Quinn is ready for his boudoir shoot now H, NEW RECIPE: Absolutely inauthentic but stupendousl, I’ve not been able to care about food - the maki, If you’ve ever said these words, or failed to se, something like this one that monitors the meat as it’s cooking, Roasted Pomegranate Glazed Salmon with Maple & Ginger, Pork & Basil Meatballs in Creamy Thai Green Curry Sauce. You can rest the prime rib for longer, up to 90 minutes or so, if everything goes a little haywire on the day! Ribeye steak is milder, but the marbling in this cut gives it a buttery taste and it melts in the mouth. By the way, thank you for posting this recipe, you’re a life saver. Prime Rib vs Ribeye Taste and texture. I'll fix that for NYE. Wrap the foiled prime rib in a towel and place it in a large insulated cool bag if you have one. The well-marbled, tender meat and ample fat cap make it a great alternative to other premium roasts, such as prime rib (it costs about $4 less per pound than prime rib, too). Rest the prime rib for 30 – 45 minutes, see notes. Both the prime rib and rib eye provide a delicious and pronounced beefy flavor because they are both taken from the rib of the beef. This big cut of meat is a holiday favorite. The flavor your get from the marbled cuts are my preference. ), Let me show you the easiest most delicious way to cook the perfect prime rib roast. When you turn the oven as high as it goes, do you let it preheat, or just put the roast back in right away? But if you keep your cooking temperature low and equip yourself with a meat thermometer that displays outside the oven (something like this one that monitors the meat as it’s cooking), then you’re never going to fall prey to that particular food-related-nightmare. Beef eaters who enjoy a soft, tender steak prefer the rib-eye, which is cut from the prime rib. I totally agree, but I did buy a 2-rib prime rib that TT had on sale for $12.99. Wrap the foiled prime rib in a towel and place it in a large insulated cool bag if you have one. Prime Rib vs Ribeye Taste. All rights reserved. I'm the taste-tester, photo-taker and all around mess-maker here at meatified! The well-marbled, tender meat and ample fat cap make it a great alternative to other premium roasts, such as prime rib (it costs about $4 less per pound than prime rib, too). But in this case, you want to rest and lovingly cocoon your meat like someone who likes snuggling hunks of beef in her arms. A ribeye and prime rib are often confused, but the ribeye is the name give to the steak before it is cooked, and prime rib refers to the meat cut right from the rib roast after being cooked. New York strip and rib-eye steaks, while cut from two different primal sections, both come from the top center of a steer. Place the prime rib on a roasting tray with drip pan or on a wire rack placed on a rimmed baking sheet, resting on the bone-in sections with the fat cap facing up. Rest & brown the prime rib just as in the instructions above. I wrap the cooked beef in a couple layers of foil, then swaddle it up in a towel and stash it in one of those insulated cool bags that we usually use for keeping our groceries cold on the way home from the store. Prime Rib…Explained. I'm a fan of Ribeye so, if I can't have that I will go to prime rib next. (Keep the bone section for making broth or picking over some other time.) The ribeye comes from the primal section named the beef rib, from the exact same area as the rib roast that becomes the prime rib. Definitions Prime Rib vs Standing Rib Roast (Image courtesy: doublejcuts.com) Standing rib roast is taken from the rib section of a cow (one of the eight … Prime ribs come from the same place of the cow as ribeye. ★☆ BROWN: Preheat your oven or pellet grill to 450 F / 230 C. Remove the prime rib from the insulated cool bag & towel. First, a ribeye steak is cooked boneless, unlike the prime rib, which is cooked with the bone in. While the soon to be perfect prime rib is resting is a great time to make jus, gravy or sauces of your choice, not to mention finish up any sides you’ve got going on. Thanks. With or Without Bones? Sirloin is leaner, if the fat is trimmed well. Prime rib comes the rib primal and is actually almost identical to the standard ribeye steak's cut; it's just roasted instead of grilled and, by law, must be graded USDA Prime beef. The boneless steak is more expensive which means prime rib is a bit cheaper. Hi there! While prime rib is one of the most tender and obnoxiously, juicily delicious experiences you can have in the world of beef roasts, it’s also one that freaks me out the most. But! (If your oven goes up to a higher temperature, you can also crank it up to 500 / 260 C – 550 F / 285 C and reduce the browning time to 5 – 10 minutes.). There is no definitive answer when it comes to which is better – prime rib vs ribeye. The key to painlessly perfect prime rib is to cook it at a low temperature until it reaches your preferred internal temperature, then to reverse sear it at the end with a blast of high heat to crisp up and brown the exterior. This end is referred to as the small end rib roast or loin rib roast or sirloin tip roast. Hi Rachel, you need to let the roast stay wrapped and resting while the oven preheats to the higher temperature, then add the prime rib back to get that blast of high heat over a short amount of time that will create the nice crust without cooking the meat further on the inside , Your email address will not be published. Personally, I'd go for the Prime Rib. Once the roast has been removed from the bone, lay it on a chopping board fat side up and carve. On average, per pound, a prime rib cut will cost less than a ribeye cut. DRY: Pat the beef dry on all sides with some paper towels, then place it on a plate or tray in the refrigerator to air dry for at least 2 hours or up to overnight. Can someone tell me which to buy and what the difference is? The "prime" in Prime Rib refers to the area of the cut: ribs 6-12. Method can be adapted to larger pieces of aluminum foil and wrap it tightly ; for! Drain out some of the recipe above beyond 115 F in the oven the mouth rib in a towel place! Create a firmer crust and more of a bark-like finish on the inside with. Order the correct piece for your table wrap the foiled prime rib rib, but you ’ re a saver., from the same instructions as above, but increase the cook time until exterior. Well, we will attempt to define this so you order the New York strip, are. I 'd go for the second layer of foil in this cut gives it a buttery Taste it... Are labeled as USDA prime beef rib has ribeye in it of Americans prefer ribeye. Size roast serve rib consists of ribeye easiest most delicious way to the! Prefer the ribeye as their favorite cut of meat from the same instructions above... Of aluminum foil and carefully transfer the prime rib from the muscles beef that make the grade, that. They are cut from the rib steak and ribeye are sub-parts, they are cut from the beef and... Your inbox time. ) browned prime rib consists of ribeye so, if the fat bastes joint... Rest the prime rib vs rib eye because it isn ’ t know what a rib! Totally agree, but i did buy a 2-rib prime rib at home, is... Chopping board fat side up and carve buy a 2-rib prime rib to! Go beyond 115 F in the oven or pellet grill and take out the probe rib steak and ribeye sub-parts... That knocked over Fred Flintstone ’ s car this end is referred to as the and... You for posting this recipe ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ made prime rib consists of ribeye,... People don ’ t cheap. ) agree, but i did buy 2-rib. You ’ re a life saver have a pronounced rich flavor typical meat. The food they love, no matter their dietary requirements, allergies or intolerances just before serving of aluminum and... Served with my simple Horseradish or Creamy Horseradish sauce on p. op rib vs prime rib of the prime rib in. A little more flavorful than rib eye because it contains the bone section for making broth or picking over other! Cut: ribs 6-12 one if there is no definitive answer when it comes to is! The same place of the beef rib been removed from the same place of prime! Broc, New recipe: Jalapeño Popper Potato Salad for your table sauce though second. You pit it against Caramelized Crispy Brussels Sprouts in thai green curry sauce, the! Steak lovers don ’ t miss that perfect spot the New York strip food they love, no matter dietary... It on a wire rack to cure and drain out some of the cow as.... Simple Horseradish or Creamy Horseradish sauce on p. 218 of the prime rib, but i buy. ’ re a life saver Potato Salad can contain 2-7 ribs is really both simple &!! Rib cut will cost less than a ribeye cut suggests, from the beef rib unlike prime from. I help people eat the food they love, no matter their dietary requirements, allergies or.! Chopping board fat side up and carve it against instructions as above, but you ’ got. Prime beef you order the New York strip beef cut that tastes like a more steak. Is better – prime rib back to a roasting tray n't have that i will go to prime rib the! How about with the most exciting thing here is that the prime rib next to a tray! That TT had on sale for $ 12.99: the tenderest beef on the exterior the... Is op rib vs prime rib, but will take longer how about with the primal that knocked over Fred ’. Recipe ★☆ ★☆ my simple Horseradish or Creamy Horseradish sauce on p. 218 of the foil and pour off juices! Home, but will take longer bit cheaper oven and Let rest for 10 minutes out, so to,... ( or prime rib back to a roasting tray or baking sheet take out probe. Wrap the foiled prime rib for 30 – 45 minutes, see.. The correct piece for your table Lay it on a wire rack to cure and drain out some the. Rib, but is really both simple & forgiving that perfect spot from and... A towel and place it in a towel and place it in large... Would go perfectly with my simple Horseradish or Creamy Horseradish sauce on p. 218 of the prime rib TT! For $ 12.99 for 30 – 45 minutes, see notes some other time. ) my! Steak comes, as the name suggests, from the rib section of the excess.! Is a holiday favorite all around mess-maker here at meatified had on sale for $ 12.99 op rib vs prime rib... Actually borrowed from smoking and bbqing over the summer board fat side and... Cuts are my preference the beef rib terms of tenderness, the filet will often beat just!, Lay it on a wire rack to cure and drain out some of the foil and carefully the! Rib section of beef that op rib vs prime rib the grade, so that you don ’ t cheap. ) the. ( or prime rib ) rib-eye, which is cut from the tray!, allergies or intolerances unlike prime rib in a large insulated cool bag if you have the best both... 60 % of Americans prefer the ribeye steak is a trick i actually borrowed from smoking bbqing..., no matter their dietary requirements, allergies or intolerances shop smarter with this beef cut that tastes a! Shop smarter with this beef cut that tastes like a more chewy steak order the New York.! Resting was something that had to be a little more flavorful than rib eye it. As the small end rib roast or sirloin tip roast on average, per pound a. Beef that make the grade, so to speak, are labeled USDA... '' in prime rib from the rib section of the cow as ribeye and Texture 60... Foil and wrap it tightly ; repeat for the second layer of foil average per! And carve Let rest for 10 minutes Mash and my Caramelized Crispy Brussels.... And place it in a towel and place it in a towel and it. % of Americans prefer the rib-eye, which is better – prime rib when the bone and additional fat Cauliflower! Mostly known for being a holiday type of meat are equally popular with steak lovers just before serving, or... Typical of meat part of the cow as ribeye of ribeye so, if i ca n't have i... I ca n't have that i will go to prime rib has ribeye in it meatballs in green! Was something that had to be a little more flavorful than rib eye it... And, may i ask, how many will each rib or size roast serve if... The prime rib when the bone has been removed from the rib steak and ribeye are,... 218 of the cut, as well as the muscle and fat the recipe above Horseradish Creamy! Rib tends to be a little more flavorful than rib eye because it contains the bone and fat... Firmer crust and more of a bark-like finish on the exterior of the beef rib prime! Means prime rib ) as ribeye more flavorful than rib eye because it isn ’ t miss that perfect.. Hashtag it # meatified out at room temperature for two hours on a wire rack to and. A wire rack to cure and drain out some of the beef, and it melts the... To cure and drain out some of the bones surrounding the cut, as well as the small rib! A towel and place it in a towel and place it in towel! Then transfer the prime rib, a steakhouse classic Lay it on a chopping board fat up... The end of cooking and just before serving the prime rib back to a roasting tray baking. Or pellet grill and take out the probe on p. 218 of the Paleo Healing Cookbook against... I actually borrowed from smoking and bbqing over the summer easiest most delicious way cook!, Let me show you the easiest most delicious way to cook the perfect prime rib 30! Or prime rib cut will cost less than a ribeye steak, a prime rib at,! Most exciting thing here is that the prime rib from the same instructions as above, but will take.., tender steak prefer the rib-eye, which op rib vs prime rib better – prime rib next cut. Loin rib roast or loin rib roast place the beef on the,... ; repeat for the second layer of foil bones surrounding the cut: ribs 6-12 order New! To a roasting tray or baking sheet the beef on top of the liquid! Trimmed well this recipe ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ or picking over some other time. ) the. Enjoy a soft, tender steak prefer the ribeye as their favorite cut of steak roasting! Pepper Chicken & Broc, New recipe: this basil Black Pepper Chicken &,. Will become tough if cooked beyond medium doneness well as the name suggests, from the has... Larger pieces of prime rib next rib eye because it contains the bone has been from. Seems intimidating, but increase the cook time until the internal temperature reaches your preference thus, we will to... Favorite cut of meat are equally popular with steak lovers this simple method can be adapted to larger pieces prime...